Are Jitters the Point? Hattie Brett on Donatella, Deadlines and New Beginnings

Former Grazia editor Hattie Brett with Donatella Versace: when the dream job looks like this, wanting more takes nerve.
Courtesy of Versace

Are Jitters the Point? Hattie Brett on Donatella, Deadlines and New Beginnings

She'd squeezed the lemon out
Gucci parties, snowy catwalks, prime ministers: former Grazia editor Hattie Brett had the dream job, but did she have nervecitement? In an exclusive for theALLBRIGHT, she explores a feeling she didn’t know she’d been missing and shares just some of the stories from other female career-changers. Why do they leave the big jobs, and what happens next?

When I used to tell people I was Editor-in-Chief of Grazia, the reaction would inevitably go something like this: “Wow, that must be so glamorous / exciting / fun / stressful / interesting.” Delete as appropriate.

Then they’d ask about the freebies.

The word “boring” never came up. And rightly so. It wasn’t unusual for my working days to start at the House of Lords and end at a Gucci party. I travelled the world to watch fashion’s leading figures put on catwalk shows on the side of a snowy mountain (true story) and interviewed Hollywood actors and prime ministers. It was glamorous, exciting, fun, stressful and interesting. But about a year ago, I also started to feel a curious sense of fatigue.

Of course I was tired. I had two kids and was in the type of two-career marriage that required a wall planner with military levels of colour coding. Gradually I began to realise this wasn’t going to be fixed by a sunny holiday.

I’d been in the role for eight years, working through a period of extraordinary change in the media. Not to mention a pandemic. And, as Sheryl Sandberg would say, I had leaned in.

Alongside my brilliant publisher Lauren Holleyoake, I’d pitched for investment and developed new content strategies to grow our audiences and revenues. We moved print from weekly to fortnightly, elevating the magazine without losing its newsiness or social impact. We launched podcasts, TikTok channels and Instagram communities. We secured cover stars we’d been pursuing for years.

When my deputy editor Hanna Woodside called late one Friday night to say Kate Winslet had agreed to be photographed for our Christmas cover, I replied: “OK, that’s it… I can leave now!” It was a joke. Until it wasn’t.

“I was in the type of two-career marriage that required a wall planner with military levels of colour coding.”

On a long coastal walk in Cornwall over Christmas, I tried to explain how I was feeling to my family. My daughter came out with something that stuck: “Mummy, you’ve squeezed the lemon out. Time to get a new one.”

She was right. I wasn’t bored with the job itself. But I’d reached a point where I wasn’t learning in quite the same way. I needed to feel creatively stretched again.

Nine months later, I’d left Grazia and was walking out of a meeting where I’d just pitched a new project to a company I’d never worked with before.

I’d been nervous enough to arrive an hour early and sit in Pret, practising my answers to the hardest questions they might ask. I’d worn a feather-sleeved Prada jacket that never fails to make me feel confident.

Walking out, with the meeting having gone well, I felt a surge of adrenaline I’d forgotten work could give me.

“NERVECITMENT!” I wrote on Instagram, without really thinking. “That feeling when you’re at the very start of something that you have no idea where it’s going…”

The replies came thick and fast. Women recognised the feeling. Others wanted to feel it again. Those conversations helped shape So, What Now?, my investigation [first via an online form] into women, work and changing ambition. When I asked women who’d voluntarily made a big career change why they’d left, many described feeling something similar.

“I’d been nervous enough to arrive an hour early and sit in Pret, practising my answers to the hardest questions they might ask.”

One woman in her early 40s left advertising after realising something had shifted. “I loved my job and my team, but I realised that something had changed,” she wrote. “Like I was a plant in the wrong pot. I felt like I was losing my sense of self, I could feel my creativity and enthusiasm was being drained. I felt sad and very tired. All the time. I thought I was ill, but it never went away.”

On a girls’ trip, friends mentioned a role they’d seen advertised that required similar skills but was in a completely different industry. “I realised I owed it to myself to try something new,” she wrote.

She went on to say she was enjoying learning again but also experiencing imposter syndrome and sometimes feeling “homesick” for her old team.

Another had walked away from 20 years in luxury fashion, including running her own brand consultancy, to study law and move into non-profit work. “I realised I was churning out copy without even thinking about it and was completely bored by what I was doing,” she wrote. “I wanted to wake up my brain and claim a career I’d always thought about, in law.”

She wanted more challenge and more purpose. She wasn’t the only one: of the 172 women who responded, 73% said they were more ambitious, just as ambitious, or ambitious about different things.

“My values no longer align with the direction fashion is heading in,” the same woman wrote. “Changing industries to work in non-profit and studying law has been like clicking on a light bulb in my brain again.”

What interests me is how often women described wanting a harder intellectual challenge, even as they sought a more manageable working life.

The woman who left advertising put it best: “It feels like I’m starting again in terms of there is so much I don’t yet know! It’s exciting and terrifying in equal measure.”

That combination is something author Tara Mohr explores in her book on women’s leadership, Playing Big. Drawing on two Hebrew terms, she offers a way of distinguishing between different experiences of fear.

There’s pachad: fear of projected or imagined threats. What if I fail? What if everyone thinks I’ve made a terrible mistake? What if no one ever wants to employ me again? Mohr argues this kind of fear can often distort our thinking because we catastrophise to such a point where we feel paralysed.

Then there’s yirah, which she associates with the feeling of entering a larger space than you’re not used to or experiencing more energy than you know what to do with. Think of presenting your own ideas for the first time, taking on a bigger, more visible role or becoming a beginner after years of expertise.

I recognise something of my nervecitment in that second description. The fear was real. But so was the promise of finding out what I could do by myself.

“Often women described wanting a harder intellectual challenge, even as they sought a more manageable working life.”

Of course, there are practical fears that come with career changes that deserve more interrogation than the idea of reframing your brain. In my survey, 44% of the women hadn’t returned to their previous earnings. So, let’s not sugar-coat. Career changes need careful, strategic planning as well as an enthusiasm for the unknown.

And you don’t have to resign to find a new challenge. It might be a project you’ve been putting off pitching, something you want to develop, a responsibility you haven’t dared ask for.

What I’m learning is that feeling nervous doesn’t mean I’m making a mistake. Sometimes it’s the opposite: a sign I’m doing something I care about.

My takeaway? The goal isn’t to build a career in which nothing scares you. It’s to build one in which something still excites you.

Find out more about Hattie Brett’s new career path and her investigation into women, work and changing ambition on her newly launched Substack, So, What Now?

Advertisement
Advertisement
theALLBRIGHT

Get theALLBRIGHT edit – a curated selection of ideas, stories and opportunities shaping modern work and life.

Get the edit
We occasionally partner with brands we think you'll genuinely find useful or interesting. Would you be happy to hear from them too?