Would You Choose My Genes? What Egg Donation Asked of Me

By Ellen Scott
"My worth cannot be reduced to a package that offers refunds if no baby is born.” Writer Ellen Scott on what a donor profile can never capture.
Courtesy of Ellen Scott
By Ellen Scott

Would You Choose My Genes? What Egg Donation Asked of Me

Imposter syndrome with added hormones
Somewhere between the questions about her grandparents and the prompt asking whether she had high cheekbones, Ellen Scott began to wonder if her eggs would make the cut. Donating twice in the UK this year turned an act of generosity into an audition, complete with regrets about the violin she gave up and hair that frizzes like an angry cat. And somewhere along the way, she found herself writing an apology to children who may not exist yet.

Do you have good genes? How good? Good enough that you would happily spread them far and wide? And if you were to sell them on Vinted or Etsy, how would you go about pricing them?

These are not commonly pondered questions, but when I donated my eggs (twice) this year, they tumbled around my brain in a perpetual washing machine motion. While overall I found the experience of egg donation deeply rewarding, an unexpected after-effect was a mental spiral over the ‘value’ of my genetic material… and a huge dose of imposter syndrome.

Let’s get through the basics first. In countries such as the United States, women who are willing to donate their eggs in aid of other people’s parenthood journeys can get paid handsomely for that gift. Egg donors in the US tend to get paid a few thousand dollars for a ‘cycle’, with payment increasing for egg donors with highly desired attributes, such as an Ivy League education, a high income, good mental and physical health, a slim build, and so on – the idea being that hopeful parents are willing to shell out for the chance of these preferred genetic traits being passed along.

In the UK, however, egg donors cannot be paid beyond ‘expenses’ – travel to appointments, paid work missed as a result of the process, the takeaway that feels essential when you are loaded up with IVF hormones and your boobs are so sore you could cry – the idea being that this prevents anyone donating their eggs ‘for the money’, rather than for altruistic motivations. Regulation by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority means it’s a flat fee of £985 regardless of how much disruption to your life gets racked up. All egg donors receive the same money, but not all women who volunteer to be egg donors will be accepted. There’s a rigorous screening process that rules out potential donors according to factors including familial medical history, lifestyle habits (smokers are unlikely to get through), age (you have to be between 18 and 35 years old), general physical health, and mental state.

When I made the decision to donate my eggs, this screening triggered a sort of competitive urge usually reserved for job interviews. I felt, immediately, protective of both myself and the eggs I planned to give away. I wanted to pass the tests and be deemed ‘suitable’, as though being permitted to the next stage would be a stamp of approval that declared not only that I was sufficiently healthy, but that my eggs – and by proxy, my self – were ‘good enough’.

I suspected I wouldn’t make it through. My family history posed no issues – at the time, all four of my grandparents were alive and in good health well into their 90s, no immediate relatives had cancer, we had no rare genetic diseases. My lifestyle was unproblematic. I’ve never smoked a cigarette and rarely drink booze. But my mental state…

The screening process for egg donation involves a lot of deep questions to check that you’ve fully understood the seriousness of what you’re doing. Why are you donating your eggs? Are you aware that when any children created using your eggs turn 18, they’ll get your name and address? How will you feel if in 18 years, someone who looks a lot like you will show up at your door?

I worried my answers weren’t up to scratch. My ‘why’ felt flippant – I don’t want to have children, so someone else might as well use the eggs that would otherwise go to waste. I had no clue how I’d feel about anything in 18 years, but probably… fine?

And then the biggie: my chronic depression. I strongly suspect there’s a genetic component to the depression that’s hung around me for decades. My mum has experienced bouts, my dad has not been diagnosed but my armchair opinion is that if he weren’t so into running, despair would dig its claws into him, too. As I detailed the periods of self-hate and general misery in multiple forms, I became increasingly sure that my application was about to get a big red ‘NOPE’ stamp. Surely, I thought, no one would want these dud eggs, tainted with mental illness.

The self-doubt continued through the forms asking for my education level, my hobbies, my quirks. I knew that my eggs would not be priced according to these attributes, as they might be in the US, but the reality was that they would still be subject to a sort of ranking. Recipients would look through profiles, decide which eggs were ‘best’, and choose accordingly. I started to fear an embarrassment akin to being picked last for a sports team at school. Why did I ever give up the violin? Why hadn’t I kept up with Spanish? My love of reading and the proud accomplishment of raising a feral kitten felt lacklustre compared to the hobbies of egg donors I imagined; accomplished sportswomen who dabbled in chess but were also, of course, stunning models – though they’d given up that work to cure cancer.

“Surely, I thought, no one would want these dud eggs, tainted with mental illness.”

And, dear god, the physical attributes component only sent me deeper into the spiral. Egg donors are anonymous in the UK, and as such intended parents don’t get to see any photos of the women who’ve passed on their genetic material. But I knew that if someone had the option to choose half of their child’s physicality, they would surely prefer someone who was absolutely stunning. I had a pre-emptive panic at the thought of parents 20 years in the future, discovering my identity and feeling they had been scammed, their children having inherited my lopsided smile, the strangely yellow colour I turn in the sun, the way my hair puffs up like an angry cat at the slightest drop of moisture in the air. The forms asked me to describe how I looked, with example prompts of ‘do you have smooth skin? High cheekbones?’. I tried to strike a good balance of accuracy and lowered expectations. But it was surprisingly difficult to break my appearance into its separate components and describe them in a way that painted a reliable word picture. I have no clue how to describe my face shape. What kind of nose do I have? Are my eyes big, small, or in-between? No clue. I gazed in the mirror and tried to pinpoint anything of note.

But – surprise! – I was approved to go ahead. Over the summer, I completed my first cycle, a process that involved self-administered injections of hormones over a few weeks, multiple scans, and finally egg retrieval under sedation. Many people have asked me what this was like and my response has been a vague ‘meh, fine’. In the run-up I was particularly exhausted, and struggled with having to limit my caffeine. I felt my own version of broody, which made me desperately want to adopt a kitten. The trigger injections made me incredibly bloated. The heavy drugs used for sedation (fentanyl!) made me so fragile I cried when my husband joked that McDonald’s was out of Filet-O-Fish.

My second cycle in the autumn was a ‘fresh’ donation, meaning that before I embarked on the injection and procedure journey someone had already selected my eggs as the ones they’d like. I was struck by a desire to email the egg bank and check they hadn’t made a mistake. But it all went ahead without a hitch and right now, unbeknownst to me, someone could be pregnant with a baby that’s made up half of my genes.

“I had a pre-emptive panic at the thought of parents 20 years in the future, discovering my identity and feeling they had been scammed.”

I feel guilty about that, particularly after looking at the amount of money parents have to pay for fertility treatment with donor eggs (this can be in the thousands). I’ve done a lot of reading into what qualities can be inherited and each bit of information I learn compounds my concern. Along with my depression, could I have lumped a child with my procrastination, which recent research suggests has a genetic component? I assuaged my guilt-related neurosis by writing an extensive letter to any parents who choose my eggs, ensuring they’re cognisant of my depression and asking them to use this knowledge as a nudge to keep an eye on their children’s mental health, to learn more about mental illness, and to provide any support needed. In the letter to any children created with my eggs, I apologised for any genetic traits I’d passed down that they didn’t like.

But I also have to remind myself that people are not simply the result of the genetic traits of an egg plus sperm. Any children conceived with my eggs will be desperately wanted by parents who will do everything in their power to raise them right. All I can hope is that by being upfront about my genetic risks, I’ll make those parents more alert to the warning signs of depression and better equipped to help their children through it. As for the wonky smile and yellow tan… it’s all character-building, right?

I have banned myself from going on the egg donation website and browsing the previews of the egg donor profiles. Comparison culture is bad enough. The last thing I need to feel rubbish about is whether my eggs are as impressive as someone else’s, and imagining potential parents scrolling through my credentials and instead opting for someone whose profile describes them as “easy-going and down-to-earth” seems a far-from healthy way to spend my time. I’m trying to detach my eggs from the prices of treatment listed on websites – my worth cannot be reduced to a package that offers refunds if no baby is born, and I cannot break it down into bit parts based on how impressive they may appear.

Ultimately, I remind myself that for me, the value of my eggs is nothing at all. I shed them each month and think nothing more of it. For the parents who need donor eggs to have children, and by nature have had to endure the emotional strife of fertility struggles, those eggs are priceless. These parents chose my eggs in full knowledge of all the potential baggage attached, because they know they will love that child so much, no matter what. Understanding this has steadied my spiral and made me realise that, while my worth as a woman is not dependent on my eggs, I can feel pretty good about myself for having given someone else a gift that will mean so much.

Advertisement
Advertisement
theALLBRIGHT

Get theALLBRIGHT edit – a curated selection of ideas, stories and opportunities shaping modern work and life.

Get the edit
We occasionally partner with brands we think you'll genuinely find useful or interesting. Would you be happy to hear from them too?